The buy button is probably the single most tested element in all of ecommerce, and it's also the one surrounded by the most received wisdom: "red converts better," "the button needs to be big," "it has to be visible without scrolling." Three claims repeated for fifteen years across blog posts, and which, taken in isolation, are either false or badly incomplete. Here's what the data actually shows on these three levers.
Color: It's Almost Never the Color Itself
The most cited case in CRO history is a HubSpot test that's become nearly mythological: a red button beat a green one by 21%, across more than 2,000 visits. Other similar tests exist: Dmix measured a red button outperforming green by 34% across 600 subjects, Monetate measured a blue button beating orange by 9%, and RIPT Apparel moved from a green button to a yellow one for an additional 6.3% gain.
If you stop there, the conclusion seems obvious: test red, or yellow, or blue, on your store. Except the detail that changes everything is almost always left out of the articles that cite these numbers: in the HubSpot test, green was the site's dominant color. The green button didn't stand apart from its visual environment, it blended into it. Red didn't win because red is an inherently more persuasive color, it won because it was the only color in the test that actually contrasted with the rest of the page.
That's exactly the conclusion CXL reaches after reviewing this whole set of cases: "the color of the button has little-to-no effect on its own. What's more important is how it changes the visual hierarchy of the page and how it makes the call-to-action stand out." The decisive factor isn't color, it's contrast and prominence.
An even more critical piece, from CRO consultant Atticus Li, goes further on the methodological side: color perception is relative, never absolute, a button is never evaluated by a human brain in isolation, it's always perceived by contrast with what surrounds it. Many color tests presented as success stories actually contained confounding variables, a change in size, contrast, or layout that came along with the color change without ever being isolated.
In practice: there is no universal "best button color." There's one rule that holds up test after test: make the button stand out from the rest of the page by maximizing contrast, whatever color you use to get there.
Size: A Question of Millimeters, Not Aesthetics
On size, the ergonomics and UX literature rests on an old principle, Fitts's Law, which states that the time needed to reach a target depends on its size and the distance to travel to reach it: the smaller or more distant a target, the greater the cognitive and motor effort required to hit it, and the higher the risk of error (or abandonment).
On mobile, where the majority of ecommerce traffic happens today, this law translates into very concrete recommendations. Apple recommends touch targets of at least 44 x 44 points (about 7mm), Google recommends 48 x 48 dp (about 9mm) with a minimum 8dp spacing between clickable elements, and WCAG accessibility criteria mandate a legal minimum of 24 x 24 CSS pixels.
But the most interesting data point doesn't come from design guidelines, it comes from actual error-rate studies. Touch ergonomics research shows that targets between 9.2 and 9.6mm keep error rates low, while anything under 7mm pushes error rates up sharply. To put that in perspective, an adult fingertip pad measures between 10 and 14mm wide, which means a 44-point button recommended by Apple (about 7mm) is actually smaller than the finger pressing on it, which explains a good share of missed clicks and accidental double-taps on mobile.
The return on size isn't infinite, though: beyond about 20mm, accuracy gains plateau, and an oversized button ends up wasting useful screen space, or even losing its legibility as a distinct clickable element rather than reading as a plain color block. A button "big enough to never be missed" sits within a precise range, not on a logic of "bigger is always better."
Position: The Real Issue Isn't the Fold, It's Availability
The classic debate on button position pits two schools of thought against each other: the one insisting a buy button must be visible without scrolling ("above the fold"), and the one that's pointed out for years, data in hand, that most users scroll without any trouble and that this rule is largely a myth inherited from print. What recent tests actually measure is neither: it's whether the button is available at the exact moment purchase intent peaks.
A test run on an ecommerce supplement store illustrates this well. On desktop, adding a sticky "add to cart" button that stays visible on the side of the screen as the user scrolls through the product page produced a 7.9% increase in completed orders and an 8.6% increase in add-to-carts, at 99% statistical significance, across roughly 2,000 conversions per variant. For a brand generating over $10M in annual desktop product-page revenue, a lift of that size would translate to roughly $790,000 in additional yearly revenue.
The same test, run on mobile with three variants (no sticky button, a sticky button that scrolls to the add-to-cart area, and a sticky button that opens a cart drawer summary), showed that the drawer variant produced +5.2% orders and +11.8% add-to-cart clicks, at 98% significance and over 3,000 conversions per variant. The variant that simply scrolled the page to the button, meanwhile, produced no statistically significant difference at all.
What separates these variants isn't the button's position in the strict sense (top, bottom, left, right of the screen), it's the number of actions required between the moment purchase intent exists and the moment a click becomes possible. A button that's always visible and triggers the action immediately beats one that has to be scrolled to, even by just a few centimeters.
What This Changes in Practice
All three levers point toward the same conclusion: none of them works as a universal recipe ("use red," "make it big," "put it up top"), they all work as friction reducers, provided they're evaluated in the page's actual context, not in the abstract.
On color, the question isn't "which color converts best" but "does my button clearly stand apart from everything around it." On size, the reference isn't aesthetics but the ergonomic range validated by error-rate studies, roughly 9 to 10mm minimum on mobile, with enough spacing to avoid accidental taps. On position, the goal isn't winning the "above the fold" argument but guaranteeing the button stays accessible at the exact moment a visitor is ready to act, which is exactly why sticky buttons perform so consistently well across longer purchase journeys.
If you want to know whether your own store has this kind of gap between design and conversion, I built AuditCRO, a tool that audits it automatically, no theme access required, results in under a minute.
Sources
CXL — Which CTA Button Color Converts the Best?
Atticus Li — CTA Button A/B Tests: Why Most "Button Color Tests" Are Worthless
Evelance — Fitts's Law and Touch Target Sizing That Holds Up on Mobile
GrowthRock — Sticky Add to Cart Button Example: Actual A/B Test Results